John Dicke Reviews

Added May 24, 2006

Proof Evident

Author: John Dicke PSY. D., J.D.
Publisher: Synergy Books
Available At: Bookstores Everywhere
Publishing Date: February 2006
Genre: Fiction: Legal/Thriller
Format: Trade Paperback
Price: $21.95
ISBN: 0-9764981-5-4
Author Email/Website: www.johndicke.com
Reviewer: Joyce Handzo
Rating: 7 Gargoyles

Proof Evident was obviously written by an author who is familiar with the legal system. The controversial and occasionally crafty plea of insanity has been shown to be effective in certain high profile cases, leading the public to wonder at its validity. In an amazing exploration of this subject, these pages highlight a case that will be sure to bring some sanity and clarity to this line of defense.

Avery Jackson, a former judge and current university professor, walks into a crowded room, kills Sheriff Hardacre at point blank range and later admits that he has no recollection of the event. The prosecutor appears to have an airtight case, but the defense lawyers decide to do some sleuthing. What they uncover is mind boggling -- literally. The psychological aspect of this murder is complicated and compelling. As the pieces fall into place, the scales of justice become weighed down with startling new facts and implications. As the case goes to the jury, readers will hasten to the final page for the much-anticipated verdict.

The legal aspect of this book was extremely well done, providing fascinating bits of information in a comfortable writing style. From the actual murder, to the arrest and the subsequent court proceedings, readers get a front row seat, complete with all the necessary explanations. As the defense attorneys pursue their own line of investigation, the ramifications of their discoveries pose new questions. The final picture of the psychological abuse suffered by the defendant provides a horrifying, yet realistic scenario.

Although the plot packs a thrilling sense of intrigue, the characterizations fell short at times. The intellectual allure of this book overshadowed what could have been a stronger emotional appeal. Irrelevant sex scenes and stilted dialogue took some of the edge off the action. Yet, the author was able to maintain a high level of interest in this unique handling of a popular subject.

Proof Evident is an amazing perspective on justice!

Return to top of page.

This page was last updated on January 1, 2008

This page and all its contents are Copyright© 2002-2008 In the Library Reviews and the individual reviewers. Except where noted, all graphics are Copyright© Eos Development and are used with permission. All book covers are Copyright© their respective publishers and are used with permission. The In the Library Reviews logo is Copyright© 2002 by In the Library Reviews/Sharyn McGinty. Site maintained by In the Library Reviews.